After plunging into a months-long period of uncertainty, the Kylr Yust case is lurching its way back onto track.
At a 30-minute hearing in Cass County Circuit Court this morning, Judge William Collins told the prosecution and defense attorneys to keep their schedules open for a trial to be held in March or April or straddling those two months.
He said he would be scheduling case reviews weekly, if necessary, “so we can get this thing resolved.”
“We’re not going to get blindsided with new things like we have here the last year,” he added.
Yust has been in the Cass County Jail since October 2017, when he was charged with murdering Kara Kopetsky in 2007 and Jessica Runions in 2016. The women’s remains were found in a wooded area south of Belton in April 2017.
Late last year, the case seemingly was headed for trial in July, when two things happened: First, Covid-19 hit, and then Yust’s defense attorneys exposed a problem that could have jeopardized Yust’s right to a fair trial. The attorneys discovered that the Cass County Sheriff’s Office and a subcontractor that handles its phone system improperly recorded numerous client-attorney calls. In addition, it turned out, a number of client-attorney emails were unencrypted and all text communication was not secure.
The “communication” was accessible to all members of the Cass County Sheriff’s office, and two deputies accessed and listened to all or part of the phone calls between Yust and his attorneys.
A big question at the time was how deeply, if at all, the Cass County Prosecuting Attorney’s office was involved in the improper recordings and other communication snafus.
In light of the flaws, the defense moved to dismiss the case or at least remove the Cass County prosecutor’s office from the case.
Judge Collins appointed a “special master,” retired Judge James Bickel, to sort through the mess and determine if Yust’s rights had been fatally compromised. Two weeks ago, Judge Bickel ruled that the prosecutor’s office “was never provided the content of the above communications” and that neither of the sheriff’s deputies who recorded the calls would testify at trial, assuring that the verboten conversations would not be used against Yust.
Judge Bickel concluded that while Yust’s right to confidential communications had been violated, “the violations do not rise to the level of prejudice that will violate his right to a fair trial.” (Although the case will go forward, the defense would still be able to appeal Bickel’s ruling if Yust is subsequently tried and convicted.)
The privileged communication problem could, in the end, be eclipsed by the biggest issue of all: How strong a case does the prosecutor’s office have against Yust?
Here are some of the shortcomings…
— The Kopetsky case is now 13 years old, and the ticking clock and calendar almost always work in favor of the defense.
— If there is any physical evidence in either case, I believe it is scant. There’s been no indication of DNA evidence and no eyewitnesses that we know of.
— Yust has consistently denied to authorities that he killed either woman. He apparently told some people he killed one or both, but, as assistant prosecuting attorney Julie Tolle told Judge Collins today, all confessions are second, third or fourth hand.
— Sitting in the courtroom, Yust does not look the least bit menacing. He is slight and impassive. His hair is cut short, and while he has a lot of tattoos on his body, none are visible with his arms covered and his T-shirt covering most of his neck.
Besides those alleged confessions, here are some of the strengths…
— Yust dated both women, and he was reputed to be hot tempered. Runions was last seen in September 2016 leaving a gathering with Yust. Witnesses at the gathering said Yust was drinking heavily and “acting very possessive towards (Runions) and aggressive towards others at the party.”
— If the state can establish that Yust was the last person to see Runions alive and that he was acting possessive of her and aggressive toward others, it would be highly incriminating.
— The biggest thing the state has going for it is that there are no other suspects. I don’t think the defense will be able to show, credibly, that anyone else had a serious beef with either woman. In other words, who besides Yust would have had a motive?
— Judge Collins is going to keep the case moving forward.
**
Before testimony begins, Judge Collins and the attorneys will travel to St. Charles County, west of St. Louis, to select a jury. (The judge ruled earlier it would be too impossible to impanel an impartial jury in Cass County.)
After a jury has been selected, the jurors will come over to Cass County, where the case will be tried.
It’s going to get interesting. I guarantee it.
Duh, a serious typo here, Fitz–a missing word, based on the rest of your story.
there are NO other suspects. Not what you published, there (ARE) other suspects.
Geez. Casey Jones would smack you with his red pencil.
Thank you for your always-gentle nudging, Tracy…Good thing you never had to manage people. You would have been worse at it than I was!
If you want to be that way, Fitz, then know that I’d have fired your ass. Rather than just exile you to the Dotte.
Now, kids, hug each other and say you’re sorry…
Okay, Mom, just don’t put us in time out…
Succinct summary. Thanks, Jim.
Thanks for the tip a few days ago on Bickel’s ruling, Steve. I could easily have missed that.
I think the word is verboten.
I get by with a little help from my friends…
Casey probably borrowed that red pencil from Tom Eblen, he of the red corrective marks fame. But I digress. Hey, it’s those guys who don’t look “the least bit menacing” that you really have to worry about. The killer over in Jefferson County, Kan., in the case I followed in 2018/2019 fit that description to a “T”.
And look at all the innocent girls hunky Ted Bundy lured into his cute little VeeWee bug.