It being close to year’s end, I could do one of those “Highlights/Memorable Moments/Top Stories of 2017” blog posts.
But I’ve got another idea. How about a “State of the City” report?
Huh? Huh? HUH? Yes, I knew you’d like that!
What got me thinking along those lines was an exchange of emails yesterday with a former KC Star reporter, Repps Hudson, who left here many years ago and spent most of his career in St. Louis. His last position was business reporter and columnist for the St. Louis Post-Dispatch. He’s been retired from the P-D nearly 10 years, about as long as I’ve been retired from The Star.
In our email exchange, my friend raised the comparison between St. Louis and Kansas City, and his seminal line was this:
“It (Kansas City) has improved sooo much. St. Louis is divided and stuck, but KC is rollin’ along.”
That was really good to hear, especially coming from a person who has lived in both cities and has a good frame of reference…Now, I’m not happy in any way to hear his assessment that St. Louis is divided (racially, he suggested) and “stuck.” I like St. Louis a lot, but I have gotten the impression in my trips over there that it’s not making the kind of strides Kansas City has made.
In one of my messages, I likened Kansas City’s progress the last 10 years to creation of a three-legged stool — the perfect stool, of course, because a three-legged stool doesn’t rock.
Former Mayor Kay Barnes (1999-2007) gets much of the credit for constructing this stool because she was responsible for two of the three legs.
Kansas City’s resurgence — and I mean the resurgence of the whole city because a city can’t be strong without a solid core — started with construction of the Sprint Center. Before Sprint Center, we had tired old Municipal Auditorium, which, although a beautiful example of the Art Deco style, dated to the Pendergast era.
Sprint Center opened in 2007. Before it opened, work began on improving downtown streets, sidewalks and other infrastructure. I remember walking around downtown with the late Bill Grigsby, probably in 1980s, with him bitterly pointing out crumbling sidewalks outside the Hotel Muehlebach, which, before it was refurbished and subsumed by Marriott in the late 1990s, was the last vestige of an earlier, prosperous downtown era.
Since the day it opened, the Sprint Center has been one of the most successful arenas in the nation, event without a National Hockey League or National Basketball Association team. It sizzles as is, with concerts, college basketball games and other events.
Another leg was added with opening of the $850 million Power & Light District, which had its genesis many years earlier as a gleam in the eye of movie-theater magnate Stan Durwood, who, interestingly, dated Kay Barnes for several years. Durwood died before he could bring his dream to fruition, but his former girlfriend got the job done. Who knows? Maybe she blew a kiss skyward the day P&L opened in 2008.
The district has had — and probably still has — its share of critics. It opened when the Great Recession was taking hold and overall has not generated the revenue that was forecast, leaving the city to supplement its operation by several million dollars a year. But that won’t be the case forever. The district seems to be going great, and it’s undeniable that, combined with Sprint Center, it turned around our downtown.
I remember going to a basketball tournament at Sprint Center in the fall of 2015 and finding, when I arrived at the center, a huge walk-up crowd, with people waiting in several long lines to buy tickets. Across the street music was blaring from a couple of P&L bars, which were jammed with people. For me, it was a blood rush the likes of which I had never experienced in Kansas City. My city had changed, I realized; it had changed a lot, and for the better.
The third and final stool leg was added in 2011 with the opening of the incredible Kauffman Center for the Performing Arts. For that, Julia Irene Kauffman, daughter of the late Ewing and Muriel Kauffman, deserves almost full credit. She arranged funding for the bulk of the $350-million project from the Muriel McBrien Kauffman Foundation. With its two sophisticated performance halls — one primarily for opera and one for symphony — it has to be up there with the best performing arts centers in the nation.
If you can stand in the multi-story lobby of that building and look out — through Moshe Safdie’s angled glass facade — at the lights of the Liberty Memorial, the Western Auto building and other Kansas City landmarks…if you can do that and not feel uplifted, your sensory gas tank is running on empty.
Since work on the first leg of the stool began, scores of new restaurants have opened downtown; construction of apartments and condominiums has boomed; the streetcar has proved a resounding success; and the Crossroads and River Market areas have contributed to the core’s revival.
We can and should be very proud of what has taken place in Kansas City during the last decade. We don’t have to worry about Omaha passing us by, and it doesn’t matter that Greater St. Louis has more residents than Greater Kansas City. What we’ve got here in Kansas City is really, really good.
As we look back, then, we can do so with satisfaction…At the same time, as we march into 2017, it’s time to look ahead again. If all goes as planned, the first leg of a new stool will be a new 800-room convention hotel at 16th and Baltimore, across from Bartle Hall. The hotel development team, led by former City Councilman Mike Burke, announced this week that it had an agreement with an undisclosed lender for a $110 million construction loan, which was the last major obstacle to getting underway.
The second leg of the new stool could be extension of the streetcar line from Union Station to 51st and Brookside — which would require approval of a sales-tax increase by voters living near the proposed expansion.
And the third leg would be…
You got it: A new, single terminal KCI.
It will happen, it WILL happen…With each additional year of aging, the nearly 50-year-old KCI is going to lose its hold on those who love it for its convenience. The warts — including that gloomy interior and those awful bullpen waiting areas — are only going to get uglier.
The wood for the new stool is on the bench, then. All we’ve got to do is start shaping, sanding, sawing and assembling. Let’s get going.
“But that won’t be the case forever.”
Fritz, you are THE incurable optimist, definitely a …the glass is half full of Guinness kinda guy: There is absolutely no data –much indication, economic trend or even anecdotal evidence– to support such an assertion.
But, you know; keep on truckin’…
Great column! The H&R Bloch World Headquarters building is a cool addition to downtown, too. And while the Bloch wing at the Nelson is not downtown, it, along with the Kauffman CPA,gives us not only great artistic pleasures, but also world-class bragging rights. And I wonder if saving Union Station didn’t help change our way of thinking about ourselves. The praise for Kay Barnes is well-deserved, No comment on the airport proposal, though.
Great point on Union Station, Vern. That’s the only bi-state project we’ve had, and it was definitely a turning point. When Kay Barnes came into office, her vision was for Kansas City was a booming corridor that she called River-Crown-Plaza. That is, starting at the River Market, proceeding to Union Station and Crown Center and onto the Plaza. The Crown Center/Union Station dimension was already there, thanks to Johnson, Clay, Platte and Jackson County voters approving the bistate sales tax for its renovation.
Jim:
A very uplifting summary of Kansas City. Thank you!!
Is the former Kansas City Star/St. Louis Post Dispatch reporter Kevin Horrigan, by any chance or is he still working?
Thanks for a great year-end review. It should be published in The Star.
Happy New Year!
Laura
Nice column, Fitz. And I think that it is important to note that this revitalization of downtown was done in a metropolitan area divided between two states, five counties (six if you include Cass) and numerous municipalities, some of which are comprised of leaders who were absolutely resentful of Kansas City. I also think that once Kay Barnes was elected, Northland leaders got on board to the idea that a healthy downtown Kansas City would benefit their area.
Most Northlanders except that idiot Sam Graves…When Barnes was running against him for his congressional seat several years ago, I attended a debate between them, up north. One of his main points was what a waste of money Power & Light had been. He said something like, “That might fly down in Kansas City but it’s not how we do it up here.”
Graves is the face of anti-big city sentiment. He’s also against rebuilding KCI. Of course, I’m sure that he has no problems with the big-city life in Washington.
Top stories of 2017? Is this going to be a crystal ball thing?
Merry Christmas.
My vision is cloudy, Gayle…I just take the stuff that’s already on the table and try to prioritize it. Merry Christmas to you, too. Thanks for your patronage.
Yes, it is encouraging to see downtown’s rejuvenation over the last decade. But, let’s acknowledge that the contentious debate over the role of public incentives will continue for the foreseeable future.
Let’s also acknowledge that there are many areas which stubbornly resist progress. Test scores in the Kansas City Public schools remain abysmally low. And, homicides this year will be the highest since at least 2008. One hopes we will also see improvements in those aspects of life in Kansas City.
When I was a child, I thought Kansas City was the center of the universe. Maybe I was right, after all.
That’s good, Peg.
Mostly agree with what you say, but I have some doubts about the following.
Mark said, what about the “public incentives”? Yes, indeed. Not only are the taxpayers on the hook for the P&L district, but how about even older developments. The Marriott downtown has been subsidized by KC for 30 years, give or take. I wonder if it will ever be self sustaining. What makes you think the P&L will be self sustaining in a mere 10 or 20 years? And now they want to build another huge hotel, undoubtedly to be taxpayer supported, when even the Marriott can’t fill its rooms? Are we back to the glory days of Bartle Hall when we were told if we only add another zillion square feet KC will attract a bunch of big conventions? (Didn’t happen, of course) Meanwhile, the less sexy KC infrastructure is going downhill, as it always does. Yes, Mayor Barnes did spark a bunch of developments. Just show me that it improved the lot of ordinary Kansas Citians. Mark me as a skeptic on “incentives.” I’ve been waiting to see a payoff, for decades.
Everything’s up to date in Kansas City
They gone about as fer as they can go
They went an’ built a skyscraper seven stories high
About as high as a buildin’ orta grow.
Everything’s like a dream in Kansas City
It’s better than a magic lantern show.
You can turn the radiator on whenever you want some heat
With every kind of comfort every house is all complete.
You could walk the privees in the rain and never wet your feet!
They’ve gone about as fer as they can go.
They’ve gone about as fer as they can go!
Oh, my God…The Oklahoma cowpoke who went to Kansas City and was bedazzled by the big city is back with a rendition of one of the greatest songs ever!
And, as Kansas City has been demonstrating ever since, we keep goin’ ferther and ferther…