The Star had three outstanding “enterprise” stories on its front page Sunday.
By enterprise, I mean stories that, while news based, are not in the category of “breaking-news” stories that must be written and published as soon as possible.
Each was a “must read,” if you are interested in keeping up with what’s going on in an around KC and Missouri government.
One story was the most comprehensive assessment in decades regarding the Country Club Plaza. It was reported and written by Joyce Smith, who has been covering retail for many years.
The story was accompanied by an excellent, color-coded map that differentiated between national and local retailers.
Under new ownership as of 2016 (from Highwoods Properties to Taubmann Centers and the Macerich Co.), the Plaza is undergoing its biggest change in years.
One thing we can expect to see is even more restaurants than are currently there. A restaurant many people are looking forward to — including me — is the Shake Shack, which is under construction on south side of 47th Street, west of J.C. Nichols Parkway. Shake Shack, founded in New York City, bills itself as “a modern day ‘roadside’ burger stand serving a classic American menu of premium burgers, hot dogs, crinkle-cut fries, shakes, frozen custard, beer and wine.”
(I’ve never known a roadside burger stand to sell wine, but I guess that’s the “modern-day” element.)
Another story was about Toby Dorr, formerly Toby Young, who, in 2006, helped murderer John Manard escape from the Kansas state prison at Lansing by hiding him in a dog crate and driving out the gate. They were captured several days later after being discovered in a love-nest cabin in Tennessee.

Toby Young, before she helped murdered John Manard escape from the Kansas state penitentiary in 2006
Frankly, I never thought we’d hear from Toby Young ever again. But damned if she hasn’t redeemed and transformed herself in the 10 years she’s been out of prison. She’s remarried (her first marriage was broken before she helped Manard escape), and she and her new husband visited Manard in prison two years ago.
That story was reported and written by Lauren Fox, a relatively new staff member. Fox did a very good job on it, starting out with some previously unreported details about the escape and then segueing to the lead-up to the escape and Young’s personal transition during the 10 years since she got out of prison after serving a little more than two years.
The third story was the closest of the three to breaking news. Reported and written by Jason Hancock, The Star’s Jefferson City correspondent, the story is about the state’s rushed awarding of four consulting contracts worth a total of about $4 million. One of the elements that raises red flags about these contracts is that officials who were appointed by the disgraced former governor, Eric Greitens, orchestrated them.
The biggest contract was one for $2.7 million that went to a company that Drew Erdmann, a top state official, formerly worked for. The amount of the contract, the goal of which is to identify fraud and abuse of Missouri’s Medicaid program, was more than the combined total of three other bids.
Hancock quoted a Democratic state representative from St. Louis as saying the contracts gave “an appearance of corruption.”
Hancock, who has many years experience covering state government, was smart to use that quote high in the story, high enough that it was on the front-page part of the story, before it “jumped” to an inside page.
**
So those were the highlights, in my view, of Sunday’s paper.
On the flip side of the coin, I was disappointed that the editorial page did not carry a complete list of The Star’s recommendations on voting in tomorrow’s primary election.
In the past, The Star has usually listed its recommendations in the Sunday paper preceding elections. It makes a lot of sense because Sunday’s paper is, by far, the biggest-selling paper of the week, and people spend more time reading the Sunday paper than any other day’s edition. Also, on the weekend before any election, people are talking about the issues and candidates and exchanging viewpoints and looking for guidance in many cases.
As a side note, I have hewed to The Star’s endorsements almost issue by issue and candidate by candidate since I arrived in KC in 1969 because I know that, with rare exceptions, The Star is motivated by what’s best for the citizens, not how to make more money, win over more readers or curry favor with one group or another.
…Today, however, I realized why the Sunday editorial page didn’t list the endorsements: They were not complete. In today’s paper, The Star recommended a “no” vote on Proposition A — the “right to work” issue — and endorsed Josh Hawley for the Republican nomination for U.S. Senate.
That’s not a good excuse, however. The Star has had plenty of time to make its endorsements and shouldn’t be weighing in on something as important as Prop A two days before the election. The full list of endorsements should have been in yesterday’s paper.
…Come on, Colleen, you gotta plan better next time…And make sure you’ve got those endorsements prominently placed on the website tomorrow!
After seeing the endorsements they did make, I was left wondering why they bothered to change out the old editorial board. Sharice Davids as a “centrist”? Please. And Barnett for governor? He was irrelevant when he ran against Sebelius over a decade ago and is so bereft of followers this time around that he had to make his new wife his running mate. Hew to their recommendations all you want if your goal is irrelevancy.
Agree on the story about the woman from Safe Harbor. We got one of our pups from them and I’m glad to see the program survived her blunder. Very well written.
Clearly, The Star’s best work lately has been the various investigative pieces and it sounds like Greitens’ contracts would be a good place to devote some resources.
On the Toby Young story, I wanted to know more about other consequences she faced besides a 2-year stay in prison. Are her children still talking to her? I saw that her son declined to comment but did he disown her? What about friends? Just curious.
Has The Star made any endorsements in state legislature races? What about the Jackson County contests? And why did it wait until the 11th hour to make endorsements in the key races? If the answer to my first two questions are no, then The Star has done a terrible disservice to its readers.
Mike, advance balloting has been going on for quite some time and they barely seem to have gotten only a few done if they were expecting to have any influence. That said, how influential are Star endorsements and are they counterproductive to the news gathering staff?
I did a few quick searches on The Star’s “search” box, and I didn’t find election stories or endorsements for either State House or Jackson County races…This situation could be of deeper concern than I thought. Certainly, with eight (now seven) editorial board members, they’ve got the manpower to review the candidates in those races and make recommendations.
…I assured a friend who read this post that The Star would have a full list of endorsements tomorrow. Now I’m starting to wonder. Maybe they will just hit a handful of candidate and issue races…which would be a big change from the past and, as you suggest, Mike, a major disservice to readers.
Frank White has been atrocious as county executive, and yet the Star makes no mention of the county executive race in its endorsements this morning. Oh well. Even though I know darn little about Merryman, there’s not a chance in the world I will vote for White today.
https://www.kansascity.com/news/politics-government/article213161779.html
I, too, appreciated the story on Toby Young. As a reporter at the Olathe Daily News back in early 1997, I covered the trial of Manard and Michael Yardley, his accomplice in the brutal murder of a guy who they car-jacked while he was sitting in his vehicle waiting for his wife to finish her hair appointment. Award-winning ODN reporter Andy Hoffman had done his usual thorough work of following the story from the murder to just short of the trial before the newspaper’s new owner turfed Andy for, basically, having integrity and character. I stayed around for about another month, desperate to get away from a train wreck and looking for a place to land. Manard and Yardley were the last murder trial I covered as a reporter. Two psychopaths if I’ve ever seen any.
“Turfed”? What’s that? And where is Hoffman now?
…Manard has the word “HOOLIGAN” tattooed across his stomach. Maybe he’s a changed man, but the label is with him for life.
Andy was fired. He’s now doing cops and courts in Iowa for the Burlington Hawk Eye. http://www.thehawkeye.com
Manard reminded me of someone I knew from junior high through college. The guy was a textbook example of the difference between a sociopath and a psychopath.
I was also extremely disappointed that there were no endorsements in the Sunday paper. I appreciate the information and research that goes into the recommendations when making my own voting decisions. What a let down. Basic stuff – newspapering 101.
Have no facts to back this up, but I think the Star’s downplaying of its political endorsements is intentional. If you schedule them to have minimal impact or skip some or write them in a way that skirts controversy, maybe people won’t direct their anger at the newspaper. I think if you’re too skittish to endorse (and explain) with confidence, you should just stop making endorsements altogether.