I took a trip back into the mid-20th Century today.
After attending the 9 a.m. service at Country Club Christian Church, where I’ve been a member several years, I attended the 11:30 a.m. Mass at St. Rose Philippine Duchesne Catholic Church on Rainbow Boulevard in Westwood, KS.
St. Rose Philippine parish is perhaps the only Catholic parish in the Kansas City area where all Masses are celebrated in Latin.
What prompted me to attend was Pope Francis’ recent apostolic letter, which placed new restrictions on where and by whom the traditional Latin Mass can be celebrated.
From news stories about the letter, it appeared the celebration of the Latin Mass might be significantly reduced. A story in The New York Times said: “Many analysts see Francis’ pontificate as the restoration of engagement with the modern world after three decades of leadership by conservative popes.”
However, the letter contained an important escape clause for Latin Mass advocates: Such Masses can continue to be take place with the approval of local bishops.
The bishop in the Archdiocese of Kansas City in Kansas is Joseph Naumann, one of many conservative bishops in the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops, and I knew Naumann would not be putting a halt to Latin Masses.
Nevertheless, I felt sure the issue would be addressed at Sunday Masses at St. Rose Philippine, and I wanted to hear what the reaction was.
I was a Catholic from birth until about 12 to 15 years ago, and I was an altar boy in parochial grade school, so l knew about what to expect.
When I got to the church (below) at about 11:20, the pews were filling up, and people were sitting or kneeling very quietly. The crowd consisted of young, old and middle-aged people, families and singles. The women had their heads covered with either hats or veils, mostly veils. Along the right wall, next to the pews, a line of people, mostly young, stood stone faced. I couldn’t understand why they were standing when seats were available, but concluded it was because they were prepared to stand throughout the Mass in case the pews filled completely.

Ultimately, the pews did nearly fill up, and I would estimate about 300 people were on hand. When the priest came out, he was wearing a green robe with gold trim and a black biretta, which is a square cap with peaks and a tuft on top. Accompanying him were two altar boys in black cassocks and white stoles and about 10 smaller, younger altar boys, also outfitted in black and white.
The priest, the Rev. Jonathan Heinricy, a slim man with a goatee, got things started by walking down the center aisle sprinkling the congregants with ample amounts of holy water.
Father Heinricy and the two other priests at St. Rose Philippine are members of the Priestly Fraternity of St. Peter (FSSP), which is active in 39 dioceses in the United States and seven in Canada. After the sprinkling, Father Heinricy removed his hat and began the business of performing Mass in Latin, facing the altar, with an altar boy kneeling on either side of him.
Even though I had a “missal” with the Latin-to-English translation, it was very difficult for me to keep track of where the priest was in the text. The Latin rolled off his lips like it was his first language, and very seldom did I hear a phrase I could identify.
One phrase I did recognize was, “Dominus vobiscum,” which means, “The Lord be with you.”
The response from the congregation was, “Et cum spiritu tuo,” i.e., “And with your spirit.”
For the most part, though, the congregants listened and mumbled a few muted responses. The priest and the ritual were the central elements of the goings-on.
The only respite from the Latin was the Epistle, the first reading, and the Gospel. Both were read by another priest, Rev. Joshua Houck. After the readings, Father Houck addressed the papal letter and said that Archbishop Naumann had sent a letter to the parish insuring that the Fraternity of St. Peter’s order could continue providing pastoral care in the archdiocese, “especially to those who desire to participate in the Latin Mass.”
In other words, Father Houck said, “I think it’s reasonable to assume things will continue to go along as they have been.”
The congregants gave little reaction, although the woman sitting in front of me turned to her male partner and smiled softly.
When it was time for communion, the congregants began filing up to the altar rail and kneeling as Father Heinricy placed the hosts on their extended tongues. To his right, an altar boy held a gold-colored paten under the recipients’ chins. After each pass down the row, Father Heinricy walked quickly back to the head of the row, where a fresh line of people were supplanting those getting up and heading back to the pews.
After communion, there was a lengthy clean-up on the altar, and then Father Heinricy turned to the congregants and said, “Ite missa est” — “Go, you are dismissed.”
The congregation responded, “Deo gratias” — “Thanks be to God.”
I thought it was over, but, no, Father Heinricy again kneeled facing the altar and started in on some final prayers, but this time in English.
The first was the Hail Mary, which, with the Our Father, is the most common Catholic prayer.
When Father Heinricy finished the lead-in to the Hail Mary, “…blessed is the fruit of thy womb, Jesus,” I was astounded at the congregants’ full-throated response: “Holy Mary, mother of God, pray for us sinners now and at the hour of our death. Amen.”
It was as if, after an hour of their voices being stifled, the congregants had been given a signal to cut loose. I almost expected a few veils to be thrown into the air, but, of course, that would have been heretical.
After a few more prayers in English, Father Heinricy walked briskly off the altar, exiting right, the flock of altar boys in his wake.
Then and only then did people began slowly leaving the pews and walking down the center aisle.
There’s one and only one way to end this post…
Pax vobiscum.
Jim, although I’m a life-long member of the Methodist Church and know very little about the Catholic Mass, I truly enjoyed the detailed reporting and commentary of your experience. Great to read copy by someone like you who knows how to report a timely, factual and interesting news item. Thanks!
Thanks, Big Dog (Richard).
Fun read, Jim. As an Irish Catholic, when people ask me what parish I go to, I say Kelly’s in Westport…
Love it.
Great read JimmyC, brought me back to my days as an altar boy at St Ann’s!
Fuck the Catholic Church! And fuck these backassward traditionalists who still go to Latin masses. I left the Catholic Church for good last year. I wish I would have left it years ago! Mid-20th century? Shit! How about mid-16th? So many lives have been destroyed by this church. The final straw for me was Bishop Johnston’s letter to the entire diocese last fall regarding the election. Even though he never mentioned Trump’s name, his letter was a thinly veiled endorsement of that scumbag. The Catholic Church needs to have its 501 C3 status revoked.
Mike Rice may use bad language, but he’s got things right. During the years my five kids went to St. Peter’s Catholic school, in what real estate promoters now call “East Brookside,” there were at least two priests now revealed to have been pedophiles.
Yesterday, I saw large numbers of congregants entering the church for the 11 o’clock Mass, and no one was wearing a mask. This in Missouri, one of the most retarded states in the nation and now a hotbed of Covid-19. Why would
any thinking person continue to be a Roman Catholic ?
I saw just one other person besides myself wearing a mask at St. Rose Philippine.
For those interested, the PBS show “In Their Own Words: Pope Francis” reveals the experiences and influences that led the first non-European pope to the highest office in the Catholic church. Watch Tuesday, July 20, at 7 p.m. on Channel 19.1. Or use the PBS Passport app.
Fascinating, nuanced take on religion, ritual and the Catholic Church, Jim. Now go over to the bookcase, crack open Flannery O’Connor’s Wise Blood and take a dive into the psychobabble of religiosity.
I don’t have it in the bookcase, Steve, but I’ll “pop in” to the library and get it. I’m an English major but never read a lot of Flannery O’Connor.
And also with you.
The “Catholic Light” aka, Episcopalian, response.
Thanks, you satisfied a long curiosity about this congregation. Any further questions, the Pope’s phone number is Etcm Spri 220
Damn, Casey, I don’t know how you got that number, but thanks. I’m sure a lot of my readers will be wanting to chat with His Holiness.